CA 06-156
Case Number CA 06-156 filed at this court on 02/09/2006
Case Category: Workers' Compensation Commission
Case Caption:
WILLIAM F. WARREN
V
H & L POULTRY, LLC
SECURITY INSURANCE COMPANY OF HARTFORD
COMMERCE & INDUSTRY INSURANCE CO.
William F. Warren (ACTIVE) Appellant's counsel:
Kenneth Alan Harper - LEAD
Commerce & Industry Insurance Co. (ACTIVE) Appellee's counsel:
John Polk Talbot - LEAD
H & L Poultry, LLC (ACTIVE) Appellee's counsel:
Gary D. Marts, Jr. - LEAD
Security Insurance Company of Hartford (ACTIVE) Appellee's counsel:
Lee Joseph Muldrow - LEAD
Trial Court: Worker's Compensation Commission
Workers' Compensation Commission
Trial Court Number: F209440
Trial Judge: Judge's Name not available in part table
------- EVENT LISTING --------
02/21/2007 Formal Orders - Court of Appeals
Submitted to the court on - 02/14/07
Appellant's Attorney - Kenneth Alan Harper
02/13/2007 Response to Motion for Attorney's Fees - Comme e
Appellee's Attorney - John Polk Talbot
02/13/2007 Response to Motion for Attorney's Fees - Secu
02/05/2007 Motion for Attorney's Fees - William F. Warre
Submitted to the court on - 02/14/07
Action = GIPDIP on 02/21/07
Appellant's Attorney - Kenneth Alan Harper
Appellant's motion for attorney's fees is granted as to
appellee H&L Poultry, LLC; denied as to appellee Commerce
and Industry Insurance Company. Griffen, J., not
participating.
01/03/2007 Mandate to Clerk
12/13/2006 Brief Costs on Appeal = Aplt $429.00 - Willia
Appellant's Attorney - Kenneth Alan Harper
12/13/2006 Majority Opinion Rendered
ACTION = OTHER OPINION ACTION (MISC)
Opinion Date - 12/13/06 Consist of 0 pages,
Cite Number - Publish - no
Karen Renee' Baker -- WRITING
Affirmed on Cross-Appeal; Reversed and Remanded on Direct Appeal. Hart and Vaught, JJ., agree.
12/13/2006 Opinion Panel
Karen Renee' Baker -- WRITING
10/11/2006 Case Submitted
10/11/2006 Court of Appeals Votesheet Issued
07/12/2006 Reply Brief Filed H & L Poultry, LLC
Appellee's Attorney - Lee Joseph Muldrow
07/12/2006 Checklist for Reply Briefs - H & L Poultry, L
Appellee's Attorney - Lee Joseph Muldrow
REPLY BRIEFS
1. TABLE OF CONTENTS
2. TABLE OF AUTHORITIES (IF ANY)
3. ARGUMENT - 15 PAGES
06/26/2006 7 Day Reply Brief Extension on Cross-Appellan
This event was tickled for 07/12/06
Action = GRANTED on 06/26/06
Appellee's Attorney - Gary D. Marts, Jr.
06/20/2006 Brief Filed Timely - Commerce & Industry Ins e Co.
Appellee's Attorney - John Polk Talbot
06/20/2006 Checklist for Appellee Briefs - Commerce & In
Appellee's Attorney - John Polk Talbot
APPELLEE BRIEFS
TABLE OF CONTENTS
POINTS ON APPEAL
TABLE OF AUTHORITIES
ARGUMENT - 25 PAGES
SUPPLEMENTAL ADDENDUM INDEX (IF ANY)
SUPPLEMENTAL ADDENDUM (IF ANY)
06/07/2006 7 Day Brief Extension - Commerce & Industry I
This event was tickled for 06/21/06
Action = GRANTED on 06/07/06
Appellee's Attorney - John Polk Talbot
05/31/2006 Record Checkout by Atty. of Record - Commerce I
Appellee's Attorney - John Polk Talbot
Number of Volumes 1
Number of Sets 0
05/30/2006 Brief Filed Timely - H & L Poultry, LLC
Appellee's Attorney - Lee Joseph Muldrow
05/30/2006 Checklist for Appellee Briefs - H & L Poultry
Appellee's Attorney - Lee Joseph Muldrow
APPELLEE BRIEFS
TABLE OF CONTENTS
POINTS ON APPEAL
TABLE OF AUTHORITIES
SUPPLEMENTAL ABSTRACT (IF ANY)
STATEMENT OF THE CASE - FIVE PAGES (IF ANY)
ARGUMENT - 25 PAGES
05/16/2006 Record Checkout by Atty. of Record - H & L Pou r
Appellee's Attorney - Lee Joseph Muldrow
Number of Volumes 1
Number of Sets 0
05/08/2006 7 Day Brief Extension - Security Insurance Company ofHartford
This event was tickled for 05/29/06
The event was complied with on 05/29/06
Action = GRANTED on 05/08/06
04/20/2006 Briefing Commenced - Security Insurance Company ofHartford
This event was tickled for 05/22/06
04/20/2006 Briefing Commenced - H & L Poultry, LLC
This event was tickled for 05/22/06
04/20/2006 Briefing Commenced - Commerce & Industry Insurance Co.
This event was tickled for 05/22/06
04/20/2006 Brief Filed Timely - William F. Warren
Appellant's Attorney - Kenneth Alan Harper
04/20/2006 Checklist for Appellant's Briefs - William F.
Appellant's Attorney - Kenneth Alan Harper
REQUIREMENTS:
17 COPIES OF THE BRIEF
12 PICTH OR LARGER FONT SIZE
TEXT IS DOUBLE-SPACED
1 INCH MARGINS ON THE TOP, BOTTOM, & RIGHT MARGI
EACH MAJOR SECTION BEGINS WITH PAGE 1
CONTENTS:
TABLE OF CONTENTS
A. PAGE NUMBER REFERENCES TO EACH MAJOR SECTIO
B. PG REF TO THE ABS WHERE EACH WIT BEGIN TSMY
INFORMATION/JURIDICTIONAL STATEMENT
POINTS ON APPEAL
TABLE OF AUTHORITIES
ABSTRACT
A. FIRST PERSON NARRATIVE
B. PAGE REFERENCES TO RECORD
STATEMENT OF THE CASE
A. FIVE PAGES OR LESS
B. PAGE REFERENCES TO THE ABSTRACT & ADDENDUM
ARGUMENT
A. TWENTY-FIVE PAGES OR LESS
B. PAGE REFERENCES TO THE ABSTRACT & ADDENDUM
C. SIGNATURE AND CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
ADDENDUM
A. INDEX WITH PAGE REFERENCES TO THE RECORD
B. JUDGMENT/ORD/DECREE APPEALED FROM INCLUDED
C. NOTICE OF APPEAL INCLUDED
CIVIL CASE
04/05/2006 Letter Orders - Court of Appeals
Submitted to the court on - 03/29/06
Appellee's Attorney - John Polk Talbot
03/23/2006 Motion to Stay and Modify Briefing Schedule -
Submitted to the court on - 03/29/06
Action = GRANTED on 04/05/06
Appellee's Attorney - John Polk Talbot
Motion of appellee, Commerce & Industry Insurance Company,
to stay and modify briefing schedule. Granted. Griffen,
J., not participating. Brief due fifteen days after
Security Insurance Company of Hartford's brief is filed.
03/22/2006 Letter Orders - Court of Appeals
Submitted to the court on - 03/15/06
Appellant's Attorney - Kenneth Alan Harper
03/14/2006 Record Checkout by Atty. of Record - William F. a
Appellant's Attorney - Kenneth Alan Harper
Number of Volumes 1
Number of Sets 0
UPS.
03/10/2006 Motion to File Belated Brief and for Brief Ti
Submitted to the court on - 03/15/06
Action = GRANTED on 03/22/06
Appellant's Attorney - Kenneth Alan Harper
Appellant's motion to file belated brief and for brief
time. Granted. Brief due within thirty days (April 21,
2006).
02/14/2006 Recusal
Wendell Lee Griffen -- RECUSE
02/09/2006 Record Lodged
Number of Volumes 1
Number of Sets 0
02/09/2006 Briefing Commenced - William F. Warren
This event was tickled for 03/21/06
Appellant's Attorney - Kenneth Alan Harper
Case Category: Workers' Compensation Commission
Case Caption:
WILLIAM F. WARREN
V
H & L POULTRY, LLC
SECURITY INSURANCE COMPANY OF HARTFORD
COMMERCE & INDUSTRY INSURANCE CO.
William F. Warren (ACTIVE) Appellant's counsel:
Kenneth Alan Harper - LEAD
Commerce & Industry Insurance Co. (ACTIVE) Appellee's counsel:
John Polk Talbot - LEAD
H & L Poultry, LLC (ACTIVE) Appellee's counsel:
Gary D. Marts, Jr. - LEAD
Security Insurance Company of Hartford (ACTIVE) Appellee's counsel:
Lee Joseph Muldrow - LEAD
Trial Court: Worker's Compensation Commission
Workers' Compensation Commission
Trial Court Number: F209440
Trial Judge: Judge's Name not available in part table
------- EVENT LISTING --------
02/21/2007 Formal Orders - Court of Appeals
Submitted to the court on - 02/14/07
Appellant's Attorney - Kenneth Alan Harper
02/13/2007 Response to Motion for Attorney's Fees - Comme e
Appellee's Attorney - John Polk Talbot
02/13/2007 Response to Motion for Attorney's Fees - Secu
02/05/2007 Motion for Attorney's Fees - William F. Warre
Submitted to the court on - 02/14/07
Action = GIPDIP on 02/21/07
Appellant's Attorney - Kenneth Alan Harper
Appellant's motion for attorney's fees is granted as to
appellee H&L Poultry, LLC; denied as to appellee Commerce
and Industry Insurance Company. Griffen, J., not
participating.
01/03/2007 Mandate to Clerk
12/13/2006 Brief Costs on Appeal = Aplt $429.00 - Willia
Appellant's Attorney - Kenneth Alan Harper
12/13/2006 Majority Opinion Rendered
ACTION = OTHER OPINION ACTION (MISC)
Opinion Date - 12/13/06 Consist of 0 pages,
Cite Number - Publish - no
Karen Renee' Baker -- WRITING
Affirmed on Cross-Appeal; Reversed and Remanded on Direct Appeal. Hart and Vaught, JJ., agree.
12/13/2006 Opinion Panel
Karen Renee' Baker -- WRITING
10/11/2006 Case Submitted
10/11/2006 Court of Appeals Votesheet Issued
07/12/2006 Reply Brief Filed H & L Poultry, LLC
Appellee's Attorney - Lee Joseph Muldrow
07/12/2006 Checklist for Reply Briefs - H & L Poultry, L
Appellee's Attorney - Lee Joseph Muldrow
REPLY BRIEFS
1. TABLE OF CONTENTS
2. TABLE OF AUTHORITIES (IF ANY)
3. ARGUMENT - 15 PAGES
06/26/2006 7 Day Reply Brief Extension on Cross-Appellan
This event was tickled for 07/12/06
Action = GRANTED on 06/26/06
Appellee's Attorney - Gary D. Marts, Jr.
06/20/2006 Brief Filed Timely - Commerce & Industry Ins e Co.
Appellee's Attorney - John Polk Talbot
06/20/2006 Checklist for Appellee Briefs - Commerce & In
Appellee's Attorney - John Polk Talbot
APPELLEE BRIEFS
TABLE OF CONTENTS
POINTS ON APPEAL
TABLE OF AUTHORITIES
ARGUMENT - 25 PAGES
SUPPLEMENTAL ADDENDUM INDEX (IF ANY)
SUPPLEMENTAL ADDENDUM (IF ANY)
06/07/2006 7 Day Brief Extension - Commerce & Industry I
This event was tickled for 06/21/06
Action = GRANTED on 06/07/06
Appellee's Attorney - John Polk Talbot
05/31/2006 Record Checkout by Atty. of Record - Commerce I
Appellee's Attorney - John Polk Talbot
Number of Volumes 1
Number of Sets 0
05/30/2006 Brief Filed Timely - H & L Poultry, LLC
Appellee's Attorney - Lee Joseph Muldrow
05/30/2006 Checklist for Appellee Briefs - H & L Poultry
Appellee's Attorney - Lee Joseph Muldrow
APPELLEE BRIEFS
TABLE OF CONTENTS
POINTS ON APPEAL
TABLE OF AUTHORITIES
SUPPLEMENTAL ABSTRACT (IF ANY)
STATEMENT OF THE CASE - FIVE PAGES (IF ANY)
ARGUMENT - 25 PAGES
05/16/2006 Record Checkout by Atty. of Record - H & L Pou r
Appellee's Attorney - Lee Joseph Muldrow
Number of Volumes 1
Number of Sets 0
05/08/2006 7 Day Brief Extension - Security Insurance Company ofHartford
This event was tickled for 05/29/06
The event was complied with on 05/29/06
Action = GRANTED on 05/08/06
04/20/2006 Briefing Commenced - Security Insurance Company ofHartford
This event was tickled for 05/22/06
04/20/2006 Briefing Commenced - H & L Poultry, LLC
This event was tickled for 05/22/06
04/20/2006 Briefing Commenced - Commerce & Industry Insurance Co.
This event was tickled for 05/22/06
04/20/2006 Brief Filed Timely - William F. Warren
Appellant's Attorney - Kenneth Alan Harper
04/20/2006 Checklist for Appellant's Briefs - William F.
Appellant's Attorney - Kenneth Alan Harper
REQUIREMENTS:
17 COPIES OF THE BRIEF
12 PICTH OR LARGER FONT SIZE
TEXT IS DOUBLE-SPACED
1 INCH MARGINS ON THE TOP, BOTTOM, & RIGHT MARGI
EACH MAJOR SECTION BEGINS WITH PAGE 1
CONTENTS:
TABLE OF CONTENTS
A. PAGE NUMBER REFERENCES TO EACH MAJOR SECTIO
B. PG REF TO THE ABS WHERE EACH WIT BEGIN TSMY
INFORMATION/JURIDICTIONAL STATEMENT
POINTS ON APPEAL
TABLE OF AUTHORITIES
ABSTRACT
A. FIRST PERSON NARRATIVE
B. PAGE REFERENCES TO RECORD
STATEMENT OF THE CASE
A. FIVE PAGES OR LESS
B. PAGE REFERENCES TO THE ABSTRACT & ADDENDUM
ARGUMENT
A. TWENTY-FIVE PAGES OR LESS
B. PAGE REFERENCES TO THE ABSTRACT & ADDENDUM
C. SIGNATURE AND CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
ADDENDUM
A. INDEX WITH PAGE REFERENCES TO THE RECORD
B. JUDGMENT/ORD/DECREE APPEALED FROM INCLUDED
C. NOTICE OF APPEAL INCLUDED
CIVIL CASE
04/05/2006 Letter Orders - Court of Appeals
Submitted to the court on - 03/29/06
Appellee's Attorney - John Polk Talbot
03/23/2006 Motion to Stay and Modify Briefing Schedule -
Submitted to the court on - 03/29/06
Action = GRANTED on 04/05/06
Appellee's Attorney - John Polk Talbot
Motion of appellee, Commerce & Industry Insurance Company,
to stay and modify briefing schedule. Granted. Griffen,
J., not participating. Brief due fifteen days after
Security Insurance Company of Hartford's brief is filed.
03/22/2006 Letter Orders - Court of Appeals
Submitted to the court on - 03/15/06
Appellant's Attorney - Kenneth Alan Harper
03/14/2006 Record Checkout by Atty. of Record - William F. a
Appellant's Attorney - Kenneth Alan Harper
Number of Volumes 1
Number of Sets 0
UPS.
03/10/2006 Motion to File Belated Brief and for Brief Ti
Submitted to the court on - 03/15/06
Action = GRANTED on 03/22/06
Appellant's Attorney - Kenneth Alan Harper
Appellant's motion to file belated brief and for brief
time. Granted. Brief due within thirty days (April 21,
2006).
02/14/2006 Recusal
Wendell Lee Griffen -- RECUSE
02/09/2006 Record Lodged
Number of Volumes 1
Number of Sets 0
02/09/2006 Briefing Commenced - William F. Warren
This event was tickled for 03/21/06
Appellant's Attorney - Kenneth Alan Harper
Date Filed:
Thursday, February 9, 2006
Caption:
WILLIAM F. WARREN
V
H & L POULTRY, LLC
SECURITY INSURANCE COMPANY OF HARTFORD
COMMERCE & INDUSTRY INSURANCE CO.
V
H & L POULTRY, LLC
SECURITY INSURANCE COMPANY OF HARTFORD
COMMERCE & INDUSTRY INSURANCE CO.