CR 02-22

Printer-friendly versionPrinter-friendly versionSend by emailSend by emailPDF versionPDF version
Case Number CR 02-22 filed at this court on 01/04/2002
Case Category: Capital - Death

Case Caption:
KARL DOUGLAS ROBERTS
V
STATE OF ARKANSAS

Karl Douglas Roberts (ACTIVE) Petitioner's counsel:
Timothy M. Buckley - LEAD
Phillip Martin Hendry - LEAD
Cheryl Vogelpohl Barnard - LEAD
Deborah Anne Czuba - LEAD
Conviction Information:
Convicted of: Capital Murder
Sentence: 000-00-000 (yyy-mm-ddd)
Sentence Type DEATH

State of Arkansas (ACTIVE) Respondent's counsel:
Attorney General - LEAD

Trial Court: Polk
Polk Circuit
Trial Court Number: CR99-70
Trial Judge: Gayle K. Ford

------- EVENT LISTING --------
03/05/2013 Mandate to Clerk

02/14/2013 Majority Opinion Rendered
ACTION = OTHER OPINION ACTION (MISC)
Opinion Date - 02/14/13 Consist of 0 pages,
Cite Number - Publish - yes
Donald Corbin -- WRITING
Petitions denied.
Ray Thornton -- WRITING
Karen Renee' Baker -- WRITING
Concurs
Hart, J., joins.
Petition to recall mandatory-review mandate; petition to
reinvest jurisdiction in the circuit court to consider a
writ of error coram nobis. Petitions denied. Baker and
Hart, JJ., concur.

02/14/2013 Opinion Panel
Donald Corbin -- WRITING
Karen Renee' Baker -- WRITING

01/31/2013 Supreme Court fully briefed ready for submiss

01/31/2013 Supreme Court Oral Argument Issued for
REGULAR DOCKET scheduled for 01/25/13 at A.M. - ORAL Argument.
1/8/13 - Laura Shue, Ass't AG confirmed

01/31/2013 Case Submitted - Orally Argued

10/12/2012 ORAL ARGUMENT CANCELLED FOR 11/15/12

08/08/2012 Printed Reply Brief Filed Karl Douglas Rober
Petitioner's Attorney - Deborah Anne Czuba

06/28/2012 Reply Brief Extension - Karl Douglas Roberts
This event was tickled for 08/08/12
Action = GRANTED on 06/29/12
Petitioner's Attorney - Deborah Anne Czuba

06/22/2012 Brief Filed Timely - State of Arkansas
Respondent's Attorney - Attorney General
Laura Shue

05/04/2012 Brief Extension - State of Arkansas
This event was tickled for 06/22/12
Action = GRANTED on 05/08/12
Respondent's Attorney - Attorney General
Laura Shue

04/23/2012 Appellant's Brief Stored in Basement - Karl D
Petitioner's Attorney - Timothy M. Buckley
5 Boxes

04/23/2012 Briefing Commenced - State of Arkansas
This event was tickled for 05/23/12

04/23/2012 Printed Brief Filed Timely - Karl Douglas Ro
Petitioner's Attorney - Timothy M. Buckley

04/19/2012 Brief due 4/25/12

04/19/2012 Letter Orders - Supreme Court
Submitted to the court on - 04/05/12
Petitioner's Attorney - Deborah Anne Czuba

04/13/2012 Letter Orders - Supreme Court
Petitioner's Attorney - Deborah Anne Czuba

04/12/2012 Motion to Toll Briefing Deadline - Karl Dougl
Action = GRANTED on 04/13/12
Petitioner's Attorney - Deborah Anne Czuba
Petitioner's motion to toll briefing deadline is granted.

04/04/2012 Brief Extension - Karl Douglas Roberts
This event was tickled for 04/16/12
Action = GRANTED on 04/06/12
Petitioner's Attorney - Deborah Anne Czuba

03/27/2012 7 Day Brief Extension - Karl Douglas Roberts
This event was tickled for 04/10/12
Action = GRANTED on 03/27/12
Petitioner's Attorney - Timothy M. Buckley

03/26/2012 Motion to File Enlarged Brief - Karl Douglas
Submitted to the court on - 04/05/12
Action = DENIED on 04/19/12
Petitioner's Attorney - Deborah Anne Czuba
Petitioner's motion for leave to file a 39-page argument or
for permission to incorporate by reference from the brief
in CR 03-780, a companion case is denied. Danielson, J.,
would grant.

02/23/2012 Letter Orders - Supreme Court
Submitted to the court on - 02/16/12
Petitioner's Attorney - Deborah Anne Czuba

02/23/2012 ORAL ARGUMENT GRANTED

02/23/2012 MOTION & PETITION TAKEN AS A CASE

02/23/2012 Briefing Commenced
This event was tickled for 04/03/12

02/23/2012 Formal Orders - Supreme Court
Submitted to the court on - 02/16/12
Petitioner's Attorney - Deborah Anne Czuba

02/15/2012 MEMO FROM STAFF. READY FOR SUBMISSION.

01/27/2012 Tendered Reply to Response to Motion to Recal
Petitioner's Attorney - Deborah Anne Czuba
Tendered reply to response to motion to recall the mandate

01/26/2012 Letter Orders - Supreme Court
Submitted to the court on - 01/19/12
Petitioner's Attorney - Deborah Anne Czuba

01/18/2012 Tendered Motion for Additional Time to Tender
Submitted to the court on - 01/19/12
Action = DENIED on 01/26/12
Petitioner's Attorney - Deborah Anne Czuba
Tendered motion for additional time to tender replies is
denied.

01/17/2012 Response to Petition to Reinvest Jurisdiction
Respondent's Attorney - Attorney General
Laura K. Shue

01/13/2012 Response to Motion to Take as a Case - State
Respondent's Attorney - Attorney General
Laura Shue

01/13/2012 Response to Motion to Recall the Mandate - St
Respondent's Attorney - Attorney General
Laura Shue

01/05/2012 Petition for Writ of Error Coram Nobis - Karl
Submitted to the court on - 02/16/12
Action = OTHER on 02/23/12
Petitioner's Attorney - Deborah Anne Czuba
Petition to reinvest the circuit court with jurisdiction to
consider a petition for writ of error coram nobis is taken
as a case.

01/03/2012 Motion to Take as a Case - Karl Douglas Rober
Submitted to the court on - 02/16/12
Action = GRANTED on 02/23/12
Petitioner's Attorney - Deborah Anne Czuba
Petitioner's motion to take as a case, motion to recall the
mandatory review mandate and request for oral argument.
Motion to take as a case and request for oral argument are
granted.

01/03/2012 Motion to Recall Mandate - Karl Douglas Rober
Submitted to the court on - 02/16/12
Action = OTHER on 02/23/12
Petitioner's Attorney - Deborah Anne Czuba
Petitioner's motion to recall the mandatory review mandate
is taken as a case.

06/26/2003 Attorney's Fees and Costs - Supreme Court
Petitioner's Attorney - Timothy M. Buckley

05/07/2003 Motion for Attorney's Fees - Karl Douglas Rob
Action = GRANTED on 06/26/03
Petitioner's Attorney - Timothy M. Buckley
Tim Buckley allowed $9,000 in attorney's fees and $52.72 in
costs for a total of $9,052.72.
6-26-03. Invoice received.

04/29/2003 Mandate to Clerk, Governor, AG

04/10/2003 Majority Opinion Rendered
ACTION = Affirmed
Opinion Date - 04/10/03 Consist of 0 pages,
Cite Number - Publish - yes
Donald Corbin -- WRITING
Ray Thornton -- WRITING
dissents.

04/10/2003 Opinion Panel
Donald Corbin -- WRITING
Ray Thornton -- WRITING

02/28/2003 Case Submitted
Submitted to the court on - 02/28/03

02/27/2003 Supreme Court Votesheet Issued

01/21/2003 Brief Filed Timely - State of Arkansas
Respondent's Attorney - Mark Lunsford Pryor
Jeffrey Weber

01/10/2003 Brief Extension - State of Arkansas
This event was tickled for 01/20/03
Action = GRANTED on 01/15/03
Respondent's Attorney - Mark Lunsford Pryor

11/18/2002 Brief Extension - State of Arkansas
This event was tickled for 01/13/03
Action = GRANTED on 11/22/02
Respondent's Attorney - Mark Lunsford Pryor

10/30/2002 Printed Brief Filed Timely - Karl Douglas Ro
Petitioner's Attorney - Timothy M. Buckley

10/24/2002 Record Checkout by Atty. of Record - . State of r
Respondent's Attorney - Mark Lunsford Pryor
Number of Volumes 2
Number of Sets 0

10/24/2002 Briefing Commenced - State of Arkansas
This event was tickled for 11/28/02

10/24/2002 Typed Brief Filed Timely - Karl Douglas Robe
Petitioner's Attorney - Timothy M. Buckley

10/24/2002 Letter Orders - Supreme Court
Submitted to the court on - 10/10/02
Petitioner's Attorney - Timothy M. Buckley

09/30/2002 Motion for Extension of Brief Time - Karl Dou
This event was tickled for 11/07/02
Submitted to the court on - 10/10/02
Action = FINALEXT on 10/24/02
Petitioner's Attorney - Timothy M. Buckley
Motion for extension of time to file appellant's brief
Motion granted; final extension.
Appellant's brief due November 7, 2002.

08/12/2002 Brief Extension - Karl Douglas Roberts
This event was tickled for 10/03/02
Action = GRANTED on 08/13/02
Petitioner's Attorney - Timothy M. Buckley

06/20/2002 Briefing Commenced - Karl Douglas. Roberts
This event was tickled for 08/19/02
Petitioner's Attorney - Timothy M. Buckley

06/20/2002 Supplemental Record Lodged
Number of Volumes 2
Number of Sets 0

06/20/2002 Letter Orders - Supreme Court
Submitted to the court on - 06/13/02
Petitioner's Attorney - Timothy M. Buckley

06/05/2002 Motion for Extension of Time to File Brief -
Submitted to the court on - 06/13/02
Action = GRANTED on 06/20/02
Petitioner's Attorney - Timothy M. Buckley
Appellant's motion for extension of time to file brief.
Granted 60 days after record filed.

06/05/2002 Supplemental Record Tendered
2 volumes

06/05/2002 Petition for Writ of Certiorari to Complete R
Submitted to the court on - 06/13/02
Action = GRANTED on 06/20/02
Petitioner's Attorney - Timothy M. Buckley
Petition for writ of certiorari to complete the record.
Granted 30 days to complete record.
'Petition for writ of certiorari to complete the record.
Granted 30 days to complete record. Appellant's motion for
extension of time to file brief. Granted 60 days after
record filed.'
Two volume supplemental transcript (tendered June 5, 2002)
filed this date. Appellant's brief due August 19, 2002;
appellee's brief due thirty days after appellant's brief is
filed.

03/15/2002 Brief Extension - Karl Douglas Roberts
This event was tickled for 06/17/02
Action = GRANTED on 03/19/02
Petitioner's Attorney - Timothy M. Buckley

02/07/2002 Briefing Commenced - Karl Douglas. Roberts
This event was tickled for 03/19/02
Petitioner's Attorney - Timothy M. Buckley

02/07/2002 Per Curiam Order
Action = GRNTPERCUR on 02/07/02
Petition for writ of certiorari. Petition granted; counsel
appointed. See per curiam this date.

02/07/2002 Record Lodged
Number of Volumes 20
Number of Sets 0

02/07/2002 Formal Orders - Supreme Court
Submitted to the court on - 01/17/02
Attorney - Attorney General

01/04/2002 Petition for Writ of Certiorari - Karl Dougla
Submitted to the court on - 01/17/02
Action = GRNTPERCUR on 02/07/02
Attorney - Attorney General
Petition for writ of certiorari. Petition granted; counsel
appointed. See per curiam this date.

01/04/2002 Record Tendered
Number of Volumes 20
Number of Sets 0
Exhibits were filed with the record
20 volumes and 2 envelopes exhibits

Date Filed: 
Friday, January 4, 2002
Caption: 
KARL DOUGLAS ROBERTS
V
STATE OF ARKANSAS