CA 06-948

Printer-friendly versionPrinter-friendly versionSend by emailSend by emailPDF versionPDF version
Case Number CA 06-948 filed at this court on 08/25/2006
Case Category: Law

Case Caption:
SUNBELT BUSINESS BROKERS
OF ARKANSAS, INC.
MARVIN WINSTON
V
THOMAS M. CORMIER, JR.
SUBWAY FRANCHISE
LYCOR, INC.
NANCY W. JAMES
NARP, INC.
ROY GORCYCA

Sunbelt Business Brokers of Arkansas, Inc. (ACTIVE) Appellant's counsel:
Matthew Keith Wren - LEAD

Marvin Winston (ACTIVE) Appellant's counsel:

Thomas M. Cormier, Jr. (ACTIVE) Appellee's counsel:
Allen Williamson Bird II - LEAD

Subway Franchise (ACTIVE) Appellee's counsel:

Lycor, Inc. (ACTIVE) Appellee's counsel:

Nancy W. James (ACTIVE) Appellee's counsel:
Kenneth Robert Shemin - LEAD

NARP, Inc. (ACTIVE) Appellee's counsel:

Roy Gorcyca (ACTIVE) Appellee's counsel:

Trial Court: Pulaski
Pulaski Circuit, Fifth Division
Trial Court Number: CV2004-10633
Trial Judge: Willard Proctor Jr.

------- EVENT LISTING --------
07/07/2009 Record placed w/CA08-320

08/01/2007 Formal Orders - Court of Appeals
Submitted to the court on - 07/25/07
Appellee's Attorney - Kenneth Robert Shemin

07/16/2007 Response to Motion to Dismiss - Sunbelt Busin
Appellant's Attorney - Matthew Keith Wren

07/09/2007 Motion to Dismiss - Appeal - Nancy W. James
Submitted to the court on - 07/25/07
Action = OTHER on 08/01/07
Appellee's Attorney - Kenneth Robert Shemin
Appellee's motion to dismiss appeal is granted without
prejudice. Bird and Marshall, JJ., not participating.

06/20/2007 Letter Orders - Court of Appeals
Submitted to the court on - 06/13/07
Appellant's Attorney - Matthew Keith Wren

06/05/2007 Motion for Remand - Sunbelt Business Brokers
Submitted to the court on - 06/13/07
Action = DENIED on 06/20/07
Appellant's Attorney - Matthew Keith Wren
Appellant's motion for remand is denied. Marshall, J., not
participating.

05/23/2007 Supplemental Record on Remand due 6/7/07
Appellant's substituted abstract, brief and addendum due 15
days after supplemental record is filed; appellee's
substituted brief, if necessary, due 15 days after
appellant's brief is filed

05/23/2007 Majority Opinion Rendered
ACTION = REMANDED
Opinion Date - 05/23/07 Consist of 0 pages,
Cite Number - Publish - no
David McGee Glover -- WRITING
Baker and Miller, JJ., agree.

05/23/2007 Opinion Panel
David McGee Glover -- WRITING

05/09/2007 Court of Appeals Votesheet Issued

05/09/2007 Case Submitted

01/31/2007 Reply Brief Filed Sunbelt Business Brokers o ansas, In
Appellant's Attorney - Matthew Keith Wren

01/31/2007 Checklist for Reply Briefs - Sunbelt Business
Appellant's Attorney - Matthew Keith Wren
REPLY BRIEFS
1. TABLE OF CONTENTS
2. TABLE OF AUTHORITIES (IF ANY)
3. ARGUMENT - 15 PAGES

01/24/2007 7 Day Reply Brief Extension - Sunbelt Busines
This event was tickled for 02/01/07
Action = GRANTED on 01/24/07
Appellant's Attorney - Matthew Keith Wren

01/10/2007 Brief Filed Timely - Nancy W. James
Appellee's Attorney - Kenneth Robert Shemin

01/10/2007 Checklist for Appellee Briefs - Thomas M. Cor
Appellee's Attorney - Kenneth Robert Shemin
APPELLEE BRIEFS
TABLE OF CONTENTS
POINTS ON APPEAL
TABLE OF AUTHORITIES
STATEMENT OF THE CASE - FIVE PAGES (IF ANY)
ARGUMENT - 25 PAGES

01/03/2007 7 Day Brief Extension - Roy Gorcyca
This event was tickled for 01/10/07
The event was complied with on 01/10/07
Action = GRANTED on 01/03/07

01/03/2007 7 Day Brief Extension - Subway Franchise
This event was tickled for 01/10/07
The event was complied with on 01/10/07
Action = GRANTED on 01/03/07

01/03/2007 7 Day Brief Extension - Lycor, Inc.
This event was tickled for 01/10/07
The event was complied with on 01/10/07
Action = GRANTED on 01/03/07

01/03/2007 7 Day Brief Extension - Nancy W. James
This event was tickled for 01/10/07
The event was complied with on 01/10/07
Action = GRANTED on 01/03/07

01/03/2007 7 Day Brief Extension - NARP, Inc.
This event was tickled for 01/10/07
The event was complied with on 01/10/07
Action = GRANTED on 01/03/07

01/03/2007 7 Day Brief Extension - Thomas M. Cormier, J
This event was tickled for 01/10/07
Action = GRANTED on 01/03/07
Appellee's Attorney - Allen Williamson Bird II

12/04/2006 Briefing Commenced - Roy Gorcyca
This event was tickled for 01/03/07

12/04/2006 Briefing Commenced - NARP, Inc.
This event was tickled for 01/03/07

12/04/2006 Briefing Commenced - Nancy W. James
This event was tickled for 01/03/07

12/04/2006 Briefing Commenced - Lycor, Inc.
This event was tickled for 01/03/07

12/04/2006 Briefing Commenced - Subway Franchise
This event was tickled for 01/03/07

12/04/2006 Briefing Commenced - Thomas M. Cormier, Jr.
This event was tickled for 01/03/07

12/04/2006 Brief Filed Timely - Sunbelt Business Broker Arkansas, In
Appellant's Attorney - Matthew Keith Wren

12/04/2006 Checklist for Appellant's Briefs - Marvin Win
Appellant's Attorney - Matthew Keith Wren
REQUIREMENTS:
17 COPIES OF THE BRIEF
12 PICTH OR LARGER FONT SIZE
TEXT IS DOUBLE-SPACED
1 INCH MARGINS ON THE TOP, BOTTOM, & RIGHT MARGI
EACH MAJOR SECTION BEGINS WITH PAGE 1
CONTENTS:
TABLE OF CONTENTS
A. PAGE NUMBER REFERENCES TO EACH MAJOR SECTIO
B. PG REF TO THE ABS WHERE EACH WIT BEGIN TSMY
INFORMATION/JURIDICTIONAL STATEMENT
POINTS ON APPEAL
TABLE OF AUTHORITIES
ABSTRACT
A. FIRST PERSON NARRATIVE
B. PAGE REFERENCES TO RECORD
STATEMENT OF THE CASE
A. FIVE PAGES OR LESS
B. PAGE REFERENCES TO THE ABSTRACT & ADDENDUM
ARGUMENT
A. TWENTY-FIVE PAGES OR LESS
B. PAGE REFERENCES TO THE ABSTRACT & ADDENDUM
C. SIGNATURE AND CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
ADDENDUM
A. INDEX WITH PAGE REFERENCES TO THE RECORD
B. JUDGMENT/ORD/DECREE APPEALED FROM INCLUDED
C. NOTICE OF APPEAL INCLUDED
CIVIL CASE

11/29/2006 Brief due 12/4/06 - Allowed 7 add'l pages in st e

11/29/2006 Letter Orders - Court of Appeals
Submitted to the court on - 11/22/06
Appellant's Attorney - Matthew Keith Wren

11/17/2006 Motion to File Enlarged Brief/Brief Time
Submitted to the court on - 11/22/06
Action = GRANTED on 11/29/06
Appellant's Attorney - Matthew Keith Wren
Appellant's motion to file enlarged brief and for brief
time is granted. Crabtree, J. would deny. Pittman, C.J.,
and Gladwin, Robbins, and Roaf, JJ., would deny enlargement
of brief. Bird, J., not participating.
Brief due 12/4/06 - Allowed 7 extra pages in statement of
the case

10/12/2006 Record Checkout by Atty. of Record - Arkansas, n
Appellant's Attorney - Matthew Keith Wren
Number of Volumes 2
Number of Sets 0

10/03/2006 Brief Extension - Sunbelt Business Brokers of
This event was tickled for 11/18/06
Action = GRANTED on 10/05/06
Appellant's Attorney - Matthew Keith Wren

08/25/2006 Record Lodged
Number of Volumes 2
Number of Sets 0

08/25/2006 Briefing Commenced - Marvin Winston
This event was tickled for 10/04/06

08/25/2006 Briefing Commenced - Sunbelt Busines Brokers of Arkansas, Inc.
This event was tickled for 10/04/06
Appellant's Attorney - Matthew Keith Wren

Date Filed: 
Friday, August 25, 2006
Caption: 
SUNBELT BUSINESS BROKERS
OF ARKANSAS, INC.
MARVIN WINSTON
V
THOMAS M. CORMIER, JR.
SUBWAY FRANCHISE
LYCOR, INC.
NANCY W. JAMES
NARP, INC.
ROY GORCYCA